Thursday, February 14, 2013

Arguments against Video Surveillance



As the use of CCTV cameras increases across the United States and globe, so does the debate over their numbers and motives. In a previous post, Arguments for Video Surveillance, we looked at four arguments for video surveillance. These arguments included peace of mind, loss prevention, crime deterrent, and crime solving.
But what about the other side of the fence? The ACLU has an entire Web site, You Are Being Watched, devoted to the “high costs of camera surveillance systems, both in terms of money and civil liberties,” and there are a large number of individuals and other groups out there that oppose “big brother” watching our every move.
So, what are some of the arguments against the use of CCTV surveillance systems?
  1. Invasion of Privacy – This is the most common argument against surveillance systems. While video surveillance is more commonly accepted in public areas, this sentiment comes into play with the use of covert and hidden cameras in almost every case.
  2. Mistrust – The use of security cameras in your home or business can make its occupants feel mistrusted. If your family members or employees are under constant surveillance, there is likely to be hostility and animosity in the air.
  3. Not Proven Effective – Studies done in California and London have found that security cameras had little to no effect on reducing the crime rate. With an increase in the sheer number of cameras in many large cities, many replacing human security guards, this is a strong argument that will be the main target of many opposing groups.
  4. Misuse and Abuse – The footage captured by CCTV cameras becomes susceptible to abuse and misuse by those who have access to it. For instance, the footage can be used to discriminate against people and for voyeurism. In the age of the internet, this is another huge deal, as can be seen by all of the “hilarious” YouTube videos out there. I doubt the subjects would find most of them as funny.
All of these reasons are valid arguments against CCTV surveillance. There are many cities and countries that have massive surveillance systems, and we will likely see a large increase in public monitoring in future, so the more the public knows about the industry and their rights, etc, the more everyone can prepare for when it happens in your little corner of the globe.
Do you have any additional arguments against the use of security camera systems? What are your thoughts? Will you fight them, or open your “public” life up willingly to being observed? Let us know – we’d love to hear from you.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

I’ve never really been concerned about being on a security camera. To some extent, I suppose they make me feel slightly uncomfortable, but only because I’m imagining some stranger sitting at a monitor watching my every move. The fact is that without a 1 to 1 ratio not every security camera can be monitored and no one has time to watch 24 hours a day worth of surveillance video. The man power it would take to go through all that video just wouldn’t be worth it. I say don’t fear security cameras, because they help when it really matters and as long as they aren’t in an area that invades personal privacy such as a public restroom, then I don’t see a problem with them. Most likely the guy on the other end of the camera is asleep at his desk, head buried in a pile of donuts.
- Ronald

Anonymous said...

You made some good points here, but I still feel the pros out weigh the cons in this argument.
- Don.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Don. Without security cameras, there would be more theft in my opinion. Security cameras may not always “catch the bad guy”, but they definitely help deter their activities…similar to a guard on duty. Except, with the security cameras, you don’t have to pay a yearly salary Among other things, security cameras can also get tied in with POS devices to overlay transactions on top of video that could be watching the POS, get tied in with access control and I/O devices and sent alerts if a camera is moved, spray-painted or comes offline. It’s all about being there without being there!
- Jonathan

Anonymous said...

this is fantastic arindam

- Russell Wane

Unknown said...

That I considered this web site to consent to all in sequence on any observation camera definitely, there along with most of carecterstiques. which revenue that have always been rather satisfied to get this web site CCTV cameras or Surveillance.

sman said...

Thanks for sharing CCTV bus solutions in dubai

shark said...

THANKS FOR SHARING SUCH A AMAZING WORK
cctv for offices in dubai

nike said...

Thanks for sharing anpr and gate barrier system in dubai

sman said...

Thanks for sharing Home Security Cameras Installation

iron said...

THANKS FOR SHARING SUCH A AMAZING WORK
GREAT PIECE OF WORK!!!
thermal camera dubai
Dubai Ip Camera

emailtaai said...

These Lock Systems Replacement Parts the traditional keys with better and more secure automation features like remote locking and unlocking. In these locks, a latch or bolt is made to cross the opening between the side of the door and the doorframe, thereby preventing access.Digital Door Locks,also known as keyless doors, the locks replace the keys with a digital screen, where you can put numeric digits as a code.